Financial anxiety is high. Why financial planners may miss the signs

The Covid-19 pandemic has made it difficult for people to answer big questions about their futures, and many financial planners are underestimating the financial anxiety that is causing, according to a survey.

A majority of financial planning clients — 71% — report experiencing financial anxiety at least half of the time, according to researchers at the MQ Research Consortium and Kansas State University Personal Financial Planning Program, who conducted the survey with support from the Financial Planning Association and Allianz Life Insurance Company of North America.

Yet on average, only about 49% of financial planners thought financial anxiety was affecting their clients, the survey found.

The disconnect highlights the fact that while money is a daily topic of conversation for financial planners, for clients it’s often still taboo, said Megan McCoy, professor of practice at Kansas State University Personal Financial Planning Program.

Moreover, there is a difference between financial stress and financial anxiety. People experience financial stress when they do not have enough money.

Financial anxiety happens when you have money, a job and all the hallmarks of financial security, but still worry that something bad is going to happen.

For many people, the constant weight of that anxiety could be worse than a negative event actually happening.

“The anticipatory anxiety is much more draining on us than actual bad stuff,” McCoy said.

Financial planners can work to better identify clients’ financial anxieties by including a questionnaire on the topic in their client intake process and by seeking training to help them better identify and manage these situations as they come up, the research found.

“Remaining curious and getting to understand where your clients are around money is essential,” McCoy said.

The survey, which was conducted between last May and June, updates research done in 2006.

The higher levels of anxiety found today may be an indication that clients are getting more savvy as robo-advisors and other products increasingly let them do their own financial planning.

Consequently, they may be better able to articulate their feelings and needs around money, McCoy said.

Today’s high financial anxiety levels are also happening in the context of the Covid-19 pandemic, where answers to bigger questions are more ambiguous. That includes everything from questions around when the pandemic is going to end to what is happening with housing and inflation.

“That ambiguity is just weighing on everybody,” McCoy said.

However, Covid-19 has improved financial planner and client relationships in one key way — the prevalence of virtual meetings — which may last once the pandemic is over.

Both clients and planners showed a preference for virtual meetings. About 57% of clients indicated they would prefer them even after pandemic restrictions end. Meanwhile, 8 in 10 planners said they plan to use virtual engagements at least some of the time going forward.

The survey also identified other areas where financial planners may improve, particularly with regard to communication and diversity, equity and inclusion.

The results from last year’s survey found that financial planners consistently rated themselves higher than their clients did with regard to communication, a reversal from the 2006 study results.

More work is needed to determine whether that is due to planners’ overconfidence or an increased willingness to criticize on the part of clients, according to the research.

Moreover, while the financial planners surveyed were more diverse than they were in 2006, more work is needed to expand the profession’s demographics, the research concluded. For example, 38% of the participants in the new survey were women, up from 27% in 2006.