Worries About a Return of Meme-Stock Mania Look Overblown

A decline that small would perhaps be more interesting to day traders than long-term savers. But the note has a takeaway for everyone: A broadening out of this year’s rally is “encouraging,” but a surge among low-quality stocks “often is the tail end of the move.”

Market breadth is a hot topic. The S&P 500 index is up 17% year to date. Seven stocks combining for $11 trillion in market value contributed 73% of the index’s first-half gains, according to BofA Securities. These are

Apple

(ticker: AAPL),

Microsoft

(MSFT),

Alphabet

(GOOGL),

Amazon.com

(AMZN),

Meta Platforms

(META),

Nvidia

(NVDA), and

Tesla

(TSLA).

The Magnificent Seven, as some investors are calling these stocks, trade collectively at 40 times earnings and are skewing valuations higher for index investors. The S&P 500 as a whole goes for a lofty 20 times earnings. The index minus the Magnificent Seven—the Frugal 493?—trades at a more reasonable 15 times earnings.

There’s more to worry about than valuations. Second-quarter financial reports are just ahead, and the consensus has S&P 500 earnings falling 9% from a year ago, on flat revenue and shrinking margins. Meanwhile, data this past week showed inflation dropping to 3% in June from 4% in May, suggesting that the Federal Reserve could be close to the end of its interest-rate hiking cycle. But

Apollo Global Management
’s
chief economist, Torsten Sløk, points out that higher rates have a lagging effect on growth, and recent hikes are likely to weigh most heavily about a year from now.

So if, on top of all that, the stock market is now sending in the clowns, maybe it’s time to take some profits. But is this meme stock rally for real?

A meme on social media is an image, video, or piece of text that spreads virally with slight variations, often attempting humor. The Grumpy Cat meme, for example, consists of photos of cranky-looking felines with user-added captions, like “I purred once. It was awful,” or “What doesn’t kill you…will hopefully try again.”

During the pandemic, traders armed with stimulus money,

Robinhood

accounts, and access to Reddit chat forums began running up prices of certain assets that appeared to be selected for ironic purposes—for example, the wrong company named Zoom, a parody cryptocurrency, and a holding company connected to the former Blockbuster video chain. Investors took to calling these punchline trades meme stocks, and chief among them were

GameStop

(GME) and

AMC Entertainment Holdings

(AMC).

To be clear, there’s nothing comic about a business making the best of selling videogames on disc through mall stores at a time when discs, stores, and malls are in decline. But there is something impish about traders sending shares of that business up 20 times in value in around two weeks, blowing up short sellers in the process.

That was early 2021, and before the end of the year, Roundhill Investments, which sells exchange-traded funds with niche themes, had launched the

Roundhill Meme
ETF (MEME). It tracks an index that selects 25 stocks automatically. Since there’s no way to screen for irony, the index uses two other factors to gauge the potential for short squeezes: a flurry of mentions on social media and heavy short-selling as a percentage of available shares.

The fund, a poor performer since inception with meager assets, is what BTIG used to measure recent gains in its return-of-the-memes note. GameStop and AMC are holdings, but the initial irony there seems stale, and the shares weren’t big gainers when the fund was running. Other holdings are odd fits. Does

Delta Air Lines

(DAL), one of the stronger legacy carriers and a solid cash generator, know that it’s a meme stock? What’s ironic about

Carnival

(CCL), the cruise operator?

Walgreens Boots Alliance

(WBA) is decidedly unfunny, even by the standards of drug chains. Its shares are sleepy, too.

I screened the MEME index members during the three days BTIG examined and found that their gains were mostly driven by fallen momentum stocks with negative earnings last year, not what I would call memes. There’s car seller

Carvana

(CVNA); bitcoin miner

Riot Platforms

(RIOT); artificial-intelligence-driven lending platform

Upstart Holdings

(UPST); two electric-vehicle concerns,

Rivian Automotive

(RIVN) and

Lucid Group

(LCID); and two providers of financial services to the crypto and momentum set,

Coinbase Global

(COIN) and

Robinhood Markets

(HOOD).

Then I screened all U.S. stocks for top gainers over those same days, and examined the list for anything remotely amusing. Realtor

Redfin

(RDFN) and streamer

FuboTV

(FUBO), each up about 30%, are fallen momentum stocks with elevated short selling, but no ironic twist. Not far behind them is

WD-40

(WDFC), a prosperous lubricant company whose sales have been picking up, and that’s about as serious as it gets.

Verdict: no meme rally—just investors grabbing at low-quality stuff. It’s unclear whether that signals trouble ahead for the broad market.

Barry Gill, head of investments at

UBS Asset Management
,
agrees that more pressure from the recent rise in interest rates is coming. “That’s more of a 2024 event than it is a 2023 event,” he says. Investors likely have too much money now in U.S. growth stocks and long, safe bonds, and they could do with a bit more cash. “It’s a long time since you’ve had five-plus percent rates on money-market funds,” Gill says. Even Grumpy Cat would approve.

Write to Jack Hough at [email protected]. Follow him on Twitter and subscribe to his Barron’s Streetwise podcast.