Lucky’s Steakhouse Replaces Beloved East Hampton Restaurant

A 25-year-old California institution is expanding to the East End.

Lucky’s Steakhouse will open its fourth location at the end of June, expanding its presence beyond Montecito, Malibu, and Soho to yet another ritzy locale: East Hampton.

The California-based restaurant is replacing the recently shuttered Cove Hollow Tavern at 85 Montauk Highway. Following the Ina Garten-lauded restaurant’s final service on May 31, 2025, Lucky’s retained the staff of the former institution, honoring local ties and ensuring familiar faces at the front of house (hiring peak season in the Hamptons is also a notable challenge). Fans of Cove Hollow Tavern can find some of the restaurant’s beloved dishes at their sister restaurant, Vine Street Cafe, on Shelter Island.

Lucky’s Steakhouse was founded by Gene Montesano of Lucky Brand Jeans, along with his friends Herb Simon and Jimmy Argyropoulos, Herb’s daughter Sarah Meyer Simon is leading the brand’s East Coast expansion.

“We opened Lucky’s in Montecito in 2000, creating a place where friends could enjoy a great meal in a comfortable atmosphere and be treated like family,” shared Herb Simon. “Two decades later, we brought that same spirit to Malibu. In July 2024, SoHo followed—a small neighborhood restaurant with great food and atmosphere. Next up is East Hampton, where I have a home and spend my summers, and needless to say I’m excited to bring the Lucky’s experience to the Hamptons.”

ForbesHamptons Pop-Ups Bring The East End To Manhattan This SummerBy Melissa Kravitz Hoeffner

Dining at Lucky’s Steakhouse East Hampton

East Hampton has no shortage of great spots for steak (East Hampton Grill, The Palm) and Lucky’s will join the steakhouse selection with dry-aged USDA Prime steaks and more menu items familiar to their guests in California and SoHo.

Highlights include Gene’s Filet (filet mignon, fresh horseradish, red-wine sauce), the Lucky’s Salad (romaine, shrimp, bacon, avocado & Roquefort), and Skinny Onion Rings (thin frizzled onions). Hamptons-exclusive plats du jour, inspired by the local fare, plus a raw bar, will also be served.

To drink, tableside martini service, an extensive wine list, and full bar, of course.

The East Hampton Lucky’s is very much inspired by the original Montecito location. Longtime artistic collaborator Peter Horjus painted Jazz Age-inspired murals of East End scenes to adorn the space along with new furnishings crafted by French atelier Maison Gatti.

Lucky’s East Hampton will be open on weekdays from 5 p.m. – 10 p.m. and 11 a.m. – 10 p.m. on weekends. Reservations available via OpenTable, and walk-ins are welcome.