Ignore Wall Street’s gloom. Stocks do better when earnings fall: strategist

But fears of a bigger meltdown by those swept up in Wall Street gloom may be in vain, says our call of the day, from the chief market strategist at Finom Group, Seth Golden, who says fears of a big recession, profit fall, housing and manufacturing crash haven’t arrived, despite a rapid pace of Fed hikes.

What investors are forgetting, and maybe Wall Street too is that “markets are forward-discounting mechanisms engaged in an ongoing operation,” said Golden, in a blog post.

While Wall Street’s S&P 500 forecasts are wide-ranging, Golden’s own expectations are on the bullish side as he is targeting 4,350 for the end of 2023. And while Wall Street worries about rate hikes, the strategist offers another chart showing that apart from outliers, higher rates really have done little to hinder equities in the past:

As for those fearing recession, Golden says really we aren’t any closer to one than a year ago when the first rate hike landed, due to a still strong job market. On that note, he also swats away Wall Street fears that the Fed is hiking into a “seemingly overvalued stock market,” as this Bank of America table chart shows that’s been the norm since the 1970s:

Golden also wants to debunk fears that higher rates and higher inflation that defined the bear market of 2022, will do the same for 2023. Firstly back-to-back market drops are a rare thing, and now back to his initial point, that markets really are “forward-discounting mechanisms.”

He notes how earnings per share rose in 2018 and 2022, yet the market fell in both years, which likely means markets were forward discounting the chance of earnings per share slowdowns in 2019/2023. His chart below shows how markets have been higher 77% of the time since 1930, despite weaker earnings:

Golden adds that one of the biggest down years in market history was in 1974, when EPS was sharply higher on a year-over-year basis. He says this pretty much flies in the face of strategists like Morgan Stanley’s Mike Wilson who has insisted that stocks are headed lower due to falling forward expectations.

“Hope that the Fed does go too far, and does find it purposefully necessary to drive a recession seems to be the last bastion of hope for the belief that new lows can be achieved during the current cycle of 2023.”

As for what investors should do, Golden told MarketWatch in an email that they’ve been buying the S&P 500
SPX,
-0.47%
since October, as that’s where they saw the market bottoming. And while he doesn’t expect a smooth ride higher, the strategist said they are “looking for pullbacks in large-cap/growth as an opportunity to increase leverage.”

While his team is more focused on the S&P 500’s performance, Golden said they are watching out for weakness to add exposure to several big name stocks, including Amazon.com
AMZN,
-2.19%,
PayPal
PYPL,
+0.30%,
Boeing
BA,
+1.49%,
Visa
V,
-0.72%,
JPMorgan
JPM,
-0.56%
and the healthcare Select Sector SPDR
XLV,
-0.17%
to name a few.

The markets

Stocks
DJIA,
+0.02%

SPX,
-0.47%

COMP,
-0.66%
are tilting mostly lower in early action as bond yields
TMUBMUSD10Y,
3.994%

TMUBMUSD02Y,
4.895%
creep up. The dollar
DXY,
-0.47%
and oil prices
CL.1,
-0.04%
are higher, while gold
GC00,
-0.07%
is falling.

For more market updates plus actionable trade ideas for stocks, options and crypto, subscribe to MarketDiem by Investor’s Business Daily. Also follow MarketWatch’s live markets blog for all the latest action.

The buzz

Target
TGT,
-3.62%
stock is rising on a profit beat and revenue growth, though the retailer’s outlook was a big miss. AutoZone
AZO,
-1.21%
stock is down on a profit miss, and Norwegian Cruise
NCLH,
+2.16%
shares are falling after a wider-than-forecast loss. Advance Auto Parts
AAP,
-4.24%
is due to report.

Theater owner and meme stock AMC
AMC,
-7.98%,
whose shares surged 20% on Monday, HP
HPQ,
-2.24%,
  Rivian
RIVN,
-18.34%,
Novavax
NVAX,
-25.92%,
 First Solar
FSLR,
+15.69%
and Luminar
LAZR,
+1.23%
will report after the close.

Zoom shares
ZM,
-6.66%
are up after an earnings beat and upbeat forecast from the videoconferencing group.

Baytex Energy
BTE,
+2.66%
is buying Ranger Oil
ROCC,
+1.88%
for $2.5 billion, including debt.

Robinhood
HOOD,
-3.38%
has received a subpoena over its crypto business from the Securities and Exchange Commission.

Investors have made Tesla
TSLA,
-1.43%
boss Elon Musk the world’s richest man again.

Opinion: Why Tesla investor Ross Gerber backed down from his activist push for a board seat

The U.S. trade-in-goods deficit rose 2% to a three-month high of $91.5 billion, while advanced retail inventories rose 0.3% and wholesale inventories fell 0.4%. The S&P 500 Case-Shiller home price index fell 0.5% in December, its sixth-straight drop, while Conference Board data showed consumer confidence fell to a three-month low.

Chicago Fed President Austan Goolsbee will speak at 2:30 p.m .

The White House says federal agencies have 30 days to get rid of TikTok. And the Feds have warned tech companies against “AI hype.”

Best of the web

How a luxury apartment complex in Turkey became an earthquake death trap for a soccer star and hundreds of others.

The best U.S. metro area for first-time home buyers is this Texas pandemic boomtown.

A year into Ukraine’s war, it’s getting harder to find homes for the animals left behind.

Amazon will soon allow employees to use stock options as collateral for home loans.

The tickers

These were the top-searched tickers on MarketWatch as of 6 a.m.:

Random reads

All hail ‘bare-minimum Monday’?

Wanted: Hip U.K. musicians for King Charles’s coronation.

Need to Know starts early and is updated until the opening bell, but sign up here to get it delivered once to your email box. The emailed version will be sent out at about 7:30 a.m. Eastern.

Listen to the Best New Ideas in Money podcast with MarketWatch reporter Charles Passy and economist Stephanie Kelton