England Are Part Of Big Three But Can’t Beat India Or Australia

LONDON, ENGLAND – AUGUST 04: Chris Woakes of England greets Mohammed Siraj of India after the end of the match on day five of the 5th Rothesay Test Match at The Kia Oval on August 04, 2025 in London, England. (Photo by Gareth Copley/Getty Images)

Getty Images

India’s six-run victory over England at the Oval to square the five-match series was one of the most thrilling ends to a Test match on record. All the slings and arrows of outrageous fortune and fortitude were there in full technicolor. This absorbing hour showed that the Test format can still offer a box set drama that the Hundred and T20 can only dream of.

BBC Radio’s Jonathan Agnew called it the most thrilling saga since the 2005 Ashes. “We’re bitterly disappointed we couldn’t get the series win, but myself being a massive advocate of the game of Test cricket, this series has been an unbelievable advert for it across the world,” said England skipper Ben Stokes.

That’s true enough, but it was another opportunity spurned for Bazball to beat one of the other members of the Big Three. It’s now seven years since England defeated India in a series, and a decade has come and gone since the 3-2 defeat of Australia in the home 2015 Ashes.

Most of those barren years came before a current regime that has taken English cricket to new highs of attacking intent. One of the biggest pluses at the beginning of the Brendon McCullum and Stokes blitzkrieg was the actual statistics.

England won 11 of the first 13 Tests under new management by risk-taking as the roulette wheel landed on red, white and blue. The opponents were ‘only’ New Zealand, Pakistan and South Africa, although the methods were compelling. There was no need to dial down the pace or artillery as long as the results column was full of big, fat Ws.

England are the great entertainers under Stokes, whose body took a well-earned break from the denouement of this gripping series against Shubman Gill’s side. However, despite the new-found roar of the Three Lions, they still lack a killer instinct to punch the lights out of a team that was on the floor and limping. To truly be the best of the Test class takes more than a great stage performance. The rat-a-tat-tat of victory after victory has tailed off with this team.

Pound for pound, England look as good as India and Australia at times as the latter are both going through some transition. The Ashes are three months away and there is something building with the return of Jofra Archer and Stokes bowling as well as ever. Zak Crawley and Ben Duckett were climbing into the Indian seamers in South London to set up a series win, but at 92-0 and 129-1, the freedom went into overdrive, skidded off the road and let the pursuers off the hook. Likewise, Harry Brook’s hack in the second innings shocked the tourists back to life just as they were flatlining.

Arguably, India could have won all three of the opening Tests. England’s love of the chase got them out of a hole at Headingley. The glorious approach of the pedal to the metal can also be a free get-out-of-jail pass for the opposition.

When Bazball was at its peak during the 2023 Ashes opener, England had the chance to punish Pat Cummins’ team at Edgbaston, but they chose to declare with centurion Joe Root still undefeated. They were cruising at Lord’s with Australia a man down after Nathan Lyon’s calf tear and then hobbled themselves with shot selection. The firepower was there; the cavalry charged too hard.

If England wants to make a statement beyond the ability to grow the game and leave a legacy that will be remembered, it’s time to be more selfish. There’s nothing like winning big series. Lifting a trophy is cool, even if, as Scottie Scheffler says, it’s a transient moment of joy.

“The one hurdle for this team is to make sure they win,” Michael Vaughan mused on BBC’s Today at the Test. Results do matter in the elite world of competitive sport. England might end up being the best team to watch, but it’s not enough.