As technology continues to evolve, the debate surrounding its impact on human life and relationships intensifies. Dr. Read Schuchardt, a communications professor at Wheaton College (IL), has identified significant concerns related to digital technology, including artificial intelligence (AI), that deserve careful consideration. These concerns encompass issues such as disembodiment, offloading intelligence to machines, the creation of multiple online personas, and the potential erosion of wisdom and knowledge.
Disembodiment: a pervasive challenge
One of the core issues highlighted by Dr. Schuchardt is the phenomenon of disembodiment resulting from our engagement with digital technology. Disembodiment is characterized by a mind-body separation, where individuals are simultaneously present everywhere and nowhere. This separation, akin to mimicking death while parodically imitating angels, raises questions about our connection to natural law and the commodification of personal information. Schuchardt’s assertion, that individuals become “pure information” donning corporate bodies, resonates with many who feel the inner restlessness that prolonged online activity can engender.
AI and the offloading of intelligence
The phenomenon of offloading intelligence to machines is another pressing concern in today’s technologically-driven world. Schuchardt argues that the convenience of externalizing memory, knowledge, and language into mediums like ‘the cloud’ has led to the externalization of our cognitive processes. This shift, facilitated by portable devices, raises questions about the potential weakening of our cognitive faculties. This shift not only blurs the lines between internal and external cognition but also challenges conventional measures of intelligence. It’s a scenario where the pursuit of information has paradoxically rendered us less informed and wise.
Multiple online selves: obscuring reality
The digital landscape has allowed individuals to create multiple online personas, blurring the lines between the real and the curated. These digital avatars, often meticulously crafted, tempt individuals to shield their vulnerabilities behind a polished facade. While technology offers the promise of connection, it also provides a means to distance oneself from authentic engagement, leaving individuals isolated in a virtual mirage. The concept of ‘ignorance,’ as presented by Schuchardt, takes on new meaning in this context: despite unprecedented access to information, the true essence of wisdom may be eluding us.
AI’s role in amplifying concerns
The proliferation of AI, particularly in the form of Large Language Models (LLMs) like ChatGPT, has catalyzed concerns in line with Schuchardt’s observations. LLMs raise questions about plagiarism and the delegation of personal queries to algorithms, potentially contributing to an environment where genuine thought and engagement become scarce. AI’s capacity to provide instant gratification might undermine the depth of human interaction, replacing the search for genuine understanding with superficial exchanges.
The intersection of AI and personal connections is a domain worth contemplating. The emergence of AI-powered virtual companions, from romantic partners to counselors, blurs the line between human interaction and algorithmic engagement. The advent of “BibleGPT,” an AI designed to address biblical queries, showcases the potential for AI to provide answers to deeply personal questions, raising questions about the nature of spirituality and human connection in an era of disembodied engagement.
Prioritizing embodied experience: a path forward
In response to these concerns, some advocate for a shift towards prioritizing embodied, concrete experiences over virtual interactions. This entails a rejection of the superficial allure of virtual realms and an embrace of genuine, shared encounters. Authors like Ryan Kemp stress the importance of disconnecting from the all-encompassing digital matrix to safeguard our ability to appreciate beauty, share love, and form meaningful relationships.
In the ongoing discourse about technology’s impact on human life, AI emerges as a central player, both reflecting and amplifying the challenges outlined by Dr. Schuchardt. The quest for knowledge and connection must navigate the intricate landscape of digital engagement, striking a balance between the virtual and the real. As AI evolves, society must grapple with the delicate equilibrium between technological advancement and the preservation of human experience and relationships.
In a world where disembodiment and disconnection are looming threats, the call to re-embrace the tangible and authentic grows stronger. The future lies in our ability to harness technology without surrendering the essence of our humanity.
Source: https://www.cryptopolitan.com/ai-and-the-disembodiment-debate/