Key Insights
- The crypto market structure bill places Bitcoin under CFTC oversight, giving it clearer legal treatment.
- Most crypto tokens remain unresolved, with the SEC’s authority still undecided.
- The bill advances regulation in parts, but leaves the wider market waiting.
The US Senate has pushed a long-awaited crypto market structure bill one step ahead. The bill passed the Senate Agriculture Committee and now heads toward a wider Senate debate.
At first glance, this looks like progress. Bitcoin finally gets clear treatment under US law. But when you read the fine print, the story is more mixed. The bill solves one problem while leaving many others open.
Crypto Market Bill: Bitcoin Gets Clear Treatment Under CFTC Oversight
The biggest change in the crypto market structure bill is how Bitcoin is treated.
The bill gives the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) primary authority over Bitcoin and similar digital assets. In simple terms, Bitcoin is treated like a commodity, similar to gold or oil, not like a stock.
This matters because the CFTC already oversees futures and derivatives markets. Many large traders and funds are comfortable with this regulator.
It also means Bitcoin is less likely to face sudden legal pressure from securities laws.
For years, Bitcoin sat in an awkward place. Everyone assumed it was a commodity, but the law never clearly said so. This bill puts that assumption into writing.
Ethereum is often grouped alongside Bitcoin in this discussion, though the bill avoids naming every asset directly. The focus stays narrow. The goal is to give the CFTC more power over spot crypto markets without rewriting every rule at once.
This is why the bill moved forward faster than other crypto proposals. It stays within the Agriculture Committee’s scope, which already oversees the CFTC.
But the clarity stops there.
Most Crypto Still Sit in a Legal Gray Zone
While Bitcoin benefits, most of the crypto market does not get the same treatment.
The bill does not clearly define whether most tokens are commodities or securities. That question is left for another fight in the Senate, mainly involving the Securities and Exchange Commission.
This keeps the core conflict alive. The SEC still argues that many tokens look like investment contracts. That means projects, exchanges, and users could still face enforcement actions without clear rules.
The bill also avoids deeper topics like token launches, staking rewards, and tokenized stocks. Those areas were part of broader market structure drafts but were removed to keep this version moving. That also explains why some voted against the bill.
As a result, exchanges can still list Bitcoin with more confidence than most altcoins. Smaller tokens remain exposed to sudden legal changes, depending on how regulators interpret existing laws.
This is why some in the industry see the bill as incomplete. It reduces confusion for Bitcoin but leaves uncertainty for much of the rest of the crypto market.
Industry Pushback Slowed a Broader Crypto Market Deal
The narrow focus of the bill was not an accident. Earlier versions of market structure legislation tried to cover more ground. Those efforts ran into resistance, including from Coinbase.
Coinbase raised concerns about proposals that touched stablecoin rewards, tokenized equities, and limits on certain crypto services. The company argued that some drafts created more problems than they solved.
That pushback helped stall a broader Senate bill tied to the Banking Committee. Instead of forcing a large compromise, lawmakers moved ahead with the Agriculture Committee’s portion alone.
This explains why the current bill feels unfinished. It is one slice of a larger plan, not the final shape of US crypto law.
The next stage will be harder. Any full market structure bill will need agreement between the Agriculture and Banking committees, plus support from both parties. That is where the unresolved SEC questions will return. However, when the entire legislation passes, banks might consider crypto a bit more aggressively.
The lesson here is simple. The crypto market structure bill moves the US closer to clear rules, but only for Bitcoin and a small part of the market.
It lowers legal risk for Bitcoin-focused products and may help institutions feel more comfortable holding it. At the same time, it leaves most tokens in the same uncertain position they were in before.