Why CEFs Crush ETFs (And 1 Set To Soar In ’22)

If you invest in closed-end funds (CEFs), you’re already miles ahead of most folks. (And if you don’t, there’s never been a better time to try them—I’ll show you a tech-focused CEF whose payout triples the dividend on “regular” stocks in a moment.)

A Trillion-Dollar Monster

The main reason why most investors miss out on CEFs (which offer tantalizing yields of 7.3%, on average, as I write this), is that the CEF market is small, with only around 500 CEFs out there in total. Compare that to ETFs, which numbered around 7,600 last year.

In fact, last year, ETFs hit a big milestone: they attracted a trillion dollars in a single calendar year. And they did that before the start of December!

Why are ETFs so popular in comparison to CEFs? The answer is more complicated than you’d expect, and it depends not just on whom you ask but when. Here’s what I mean by that: in the early 2010s when ETF launches surged tenfold, their biggest appeal could be summarized in a simple phrase: passive investing at lower fees.

Nowadays, the argument for ETFs has evolved with the emergence of the actively managed offerings. The most famous example is the Ark Innovation ETF (ARKK), a tech-focused ETF led by its media-savvy CEO, Cathie Wood.

With a shocking 568% return from inception in 2014 to the start of 2021, ARKK looked like a miracle. But this hot streak has run cold lately.

As a result, investor interest in active ETFs has cooled off, with the third act of ETF investing coming to a close as we embark on 2022.

This CEF Took on Cathie Wood—and Won

This is where CEFs come in, because even though they charge higher fees than active or passive ETFs, they more than make up for those fees with their high dividends (as I said, 7.3% payouts are the average here) and outperformance, with a growing number of CEFs (currently over 200!) beating their indexes lately. It’s hard to imagine that these strengths won’t pull in a lot more investors in the future.

To see what I mean, let’s compare one such CEF—the Columbia Seligman Premium Tech Growth Fund (STK)—to the index and Cathie Wood’s offering. STK holds big name techs like Microsoft (MSFT) and Apple (AAPL), in addition to companies that supply those big names, like semiconductor maker Lam Research (LAM) and testing-gear manufacturer Teradyne (TER).

With strong outperformance compared to the index and ARKK, STK is the clear winner for 2021. And while its 3.8% dividend is pretty small by CEF standards, it’s still pretty compelling compared to most of the ETF competition and to your typical S&P 500 stock, which yields a miserly 1.2% today.

Michael Foster is the Lead Research Analyst for Contrarian Outlook. For more great income ideas, click here for our latest report “Indestructible Income: 5 Bargain Funds with Safe 7.5% Dividends.”

Disclosure: none