How America Can Reform Immigration Without Chaos

The current U.S. immigration policy involves brutality, terror and excesses. Immigration reform is needed, but not the kind currently on offer.

getty

Implementing Reforms That Bring About Order And Economic Stability

U.S. immigration reform is a persistent challenge because the country is divided and seemingly unable to agree on how to change the system that is outdated and designed for a world that no longer exists. At the same time, multiple studies establish that America needs immigration because it fuels the nation’s growth—bringing workers, innovators, families, and fresh energy that keep the economy strong and the country vibrant. Meanwhile, however, nearly 125 million people worldwide have been forcibly displaced and need a place to live, according to the UN Refugee Agency (UNHCR). That problem is knocking on our door, and it won’t go away. While we can’t help everyone who needs a home, that said, is it possible for America to be both firm on immigration limits in protecting the nation’s borders but also fair in facilitating much-needed lawful immigration? The answer is yes. Here is a practical blueprint to do just that. What is more, many experts and institutions have already endorsed it in principle.

Enforce U.S. Law Precisely

The Supreme Court has been very clear about immigration ICE raids within the United States. The Court has ruled that roving patrols cannot stop a vehicle “when the only reason for suspicion is that the occupants seem to be of Mexican descent.” The Court has indicated that precision, probable cause, due process, and judicial review are not optional; they form the foundation of constitutional rights. Getting this right is crucial. Haphazard sweeps that also catch citizens or legal residents undermine trust and put additional pressure on courts already under strain. The Government Accountability Office reported that “as of July 2024, EOIR reported a backlog of nearly 3.5 million pending cases.” This situation is unmanageable and needs to change.

Current Legal Immigration Avenues Are Not Realistic

Americans often ask why today’s migrants can’t “just come legally.” The Migration Policy Institute provides context: “In FY 2023, nearly 1.2 million immigrants became lawful permanent residents.” That is roughly the long-term norm, even as global displacement and new residence need have risen sharply, ie. 125 million. UNHCR indicates that, “The main drivers of displacement remain large conflicts like Sudan, Myanmar and Ukraine.” A decade of consistent year-over-year increases in displacements cries out for attention. In America, the result is that as safe, timely legal pathways are backlogged or even blocked, more people are likely to take the risk of irregular routes.

Create A More Realistic Front Door Sponsorship Program

There is a proven way to realistically expand needed legal, orderly entry without overburdening public budgets and it is community sponsorship. Canada has set the standard for decades. The Government of Canada reports that: “327,000 refugees have been welcomed by private sponsors since 1979.” Sponsors provide housing and essentials during the first year—this is exactly the kind of civic partnership Americans admire and should have.

Actually, the United States has started moving in this direction. The State Department states that the Welcome Corps program “empowers everyday Americans to play a leading role in welcoming refugees… and supporting their resettlement and integration.” This approach can be expanded and integrated into the core of the U.S. immigration program. What is required is to formalize a modern sponsorship pathway in law—accessible to families, employers, unions, faith communities, universities, and qualified NGOs—combined with medical and security screening and a clear, time‑limited route to permanent residency for those who meet the criteria.

Deal With the 11 Million Undocumented Already Here

Apart from deporting hardened criminals, estimated to consist of say about 2 million of the 11 million undocumented immigrants in the United States and who most everyone would agree should be deported, there are three options for dealing with the remaining 9 million: mass deportation, permanent exile, or structured legalization with penalties. Many economists and analysts argue that mass removal is unrealistic due to cost and practicality. For example, the American Action Forum’s assessment is straightforward: “it would take roughly 20 years” to deport everyone. A more recent congressional analysis concluded that a one‑time operation would cost “at least $315 billion.” Realistically, this is just not going to work. What is needed instead is a one‑time program for long‑term residents (e.g., those with 10+ years of presence) who have no serious crimes, requiring them to register with the USCIS, pay all taxes (or enter repayment), complete significant community service, pay a fine, and pass background checks. The outcome would be legal work, stability for families, and higher tax compliance—without rewarding recent illegal entry.

Match Labor Reality With Law

From farms to construction, hospitality, and logistics, employers report ongoing demand for workers. The American Farm Bureau is clear: “American agriculture depends on a skilled, reliable workforce.” Guest‑worker programs must address both year‑round and seasonal needs with strong protections for workers—and ensure predictable, enforceable outcomes when contracts conclude.

Employer verification should support this. The Department of Homeland Security explains: “E‑Verify is a web‑based system that allows enrolled employers to confirm the eligibility of their employees to work in the United States.” When used correctly—along with a swift appeals process for name or data mismatches—it safeguards compliant employers and discourages underground hiring. The oversight must be genuine. However, government review has revealed that the tool’s integrity and agency monitoring require strengthening.

Modernize Identity for Refugees and Asylum Systems

A persistent, solvable issue in humanitarian aid worldwide is identity. The World Bank’s ID4D initiative estimates “approximately 850 million people lack official ID.” Without a verifiable identity program, aid delivery becomes less efficient and legal procedures slow down. UNHCR has noted that biometrics are “an integral component of registration” in more than 90 country operations, enhancing accuracy and reducing fraud. When well managed, these tools help speed up legitimate cases through legal channels and reduce the market for smugglers and crime.

Keep Eyes on Root Causes

Any lasting solution must tackle the fires upwind. UNHCR highlights that, “The main drivers of displacement remain large conflicts like Sudan, Myanmar and Ukraine.” Fewer wars, more focused development, and stricter anti‑corruption efforts abroad lower border pressures far more affordably in the long run than emergency responses do today.

A Legislative Package Congress Can Pass

A serious fix is not just a slogan; it’s a bill. The elements are not radical and, in parts, already bipartisan in spirit.

• Constitutional enforcement: clear, court-tested standards that prevent broad errors and safeguard public safety.
• A scaled sponsorship system as a main legal pathway, based on successful existing programs.
• A tough but fair one-time legalization for long-term, law-abiding residents—covering fines, taxes, service, and background checks—bringing millions onto the books. Costly mass deportation is neither credible nor fiscally responsible and is tearing the country apart unnecessarily since it is not the solution, no matter what is done.
• Modern labour channels (expanded and better-designed visas), along with employer verification that is accurate, monitored, and appealable.
• Digital identity upgrades in refugee processing, enhancing lawful movement and decreasing fraud.
• Strategic investments in stability at the onset of displacement.

The Payoff: Order With Decency

This isn’t about opening America’s doors to “everyone.” But it is about U.S. immigration reform that takes responsibility for defining a bigger, smarter front door; restoring constitutional enforcement; and replacing showboating in politics with measurable results. This is not a noble ideal for America. It is an absolute necessity for it. The path exists and is outlined here and a Daniel Stih podcast with more details sets it all out here. Key institutions and experts have already pointed all this out. The country deserves a system that is lawful without being cruel, humane without being naive, and modern enough to meet a dynamic, ever-changing world.