‘Peacemaker’ Episode 8 Finale Theory Shot Down By James Gunn

James Gunn is the most verbose man in the entire superhero industry, and he is happy to discuss his DC projects openly pretty much every day. He’s now addressing questions related to Peacemaker episode 7 ahead of the finale, and has already axed a popular fan theory about the end of the episode.

One of the not-evil doppelgangers in the Nazi-filled Earth-X is Vigilante, resistance fighter. He joins Prime Vigilante to go rescue his friends, and helps kill Auggie, moments after Peacemaker realizes that perhaps he’s not an evil Nazi like the rest.

Forbes‘Peacemaker’ Episode 7 Finally Has A Twist No One Saw Coming

The theory, however, is that in the scramble to leave the world through the portal, the moment where one Vigilante makes it through the door with Harcourt and the other Vigilante stays behind to fight the cops and presumably die, that it was actually Vigilante Prime, not Earth-X Vigilante. They switched at the last minute, and Peacemaker’s actual friend is now stuck in Earth-X. The other one, who hates Peacemaker, is now in the “normal” world.

Source: https://www.forbes.com/sites/paultassi/2025/10/06/peacemaker-episode-8-finale-theory-shot-down-by-james-gunn/