Organizations lacking a specialist architecture often push specialists into people manager roles, even if their passion lies elsewhere. This can lead to talented specialists struggling with managerial duties while maintaining their field expertise, creating business challenges.
Frontline leaders who do not fully value their managerial roles can face myriad challenges:
- They may find an equilibrium between their obligations and expectations as leaders and their duties and contributions as individual specialists.
- They may experience an overwhelming surge when their direct reports reach out with questions or concerns, which could lead to a consequential breakdown in effective communication.
- They might inadvertently compete with their direct reports rather than foster an environment that encourages growth, development, and skills improvement.
This type of scenario could result in delayed or non-responsive addressing of performance issues, as managers may opt to shoulder more work themselves rather than addressing the performance gaps of their team members.
The Pitfall of Misaligned Roles: Why Specialist-to-Manager Isn’t Always the Answer
The negative ramifications of frontline leaders failing to thrive in their managerial roles can permeate throughout the organization, causing a significant ripple effect. The next tier of management, the leaders of leaders, may be compelled to intervene and cover the frontline manager’s deficiencies, thereby leading to a surge in skip-level conversations and an undesirable level of micromanagement.
This managerial overreach could obstruct the overall performance pipeline of the organization, resulting in each leadership layer operating below its intended and optimal level of function.
To redress this issue, organizations must focus on creating an enticing specialist architecture. This would mean carving out explicit and attractive career paths that allow specialists to flourish and climb the corporate ladder within their respective fields without feeling forced into transitioning into managerial roles.
By recognizing the invaluable contribution of specialists’ expertise, organizations can create a culture that promotes, rewards, and encourages specialists to shine in their roles and make a meaningful contribution to the organization’s success.
Beyond Architecture: The Perks and Privileges Dilemma
Correcting this issue demands more than a mere organizational chart; it requires a thoughtful specialist architecture. This roadmap will define clear, compelling career trajectories for specialists to grow within their field without forcing them into managerial roles.
This process begins with a few key questions:
- What are all the other things your organization offers the leaders but does not offer to specialists?
- Do you offer transition programs for leaders moving from one role to another?
- If yes, do you also offer specialist transition programs to your specialists when they are moved from one level to another?
- Do you have an annual “leadership forum” where executive leaders get together, and the CEO speaks about the future, highly inspiring presenters are invited, nice dinners and accommodation, etc?
- Do you have the same for your specialist? If not, you need to rethink.
The Future Belongs to Specialists
A strategic shift towards embracing a specialist architecture will benefit not just the individual experts but is critical for bolstering the organization’s overall agility, efficiency, and competitive edge.
This isn’t just a specialist issue; it’s an organizational imperative.
It is of utmost importance that organizations exercise caution against pushing specialists into managerial roles for the wrong reasons. By developing and implementing a specialist architecture that accommodates vertical career progression and duly acknowledges the value of expertise, organizations can guarantee that specialists are given the opportunity to thrive and excel in their field.
This strategic approach will not only benefit the individual specialists in their career growth but will also significantly contribute to the organization’s overall agility, efficiency, and success.
Source: https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbesbooksauthors/2023/12/05/navigating-career-progression-specialist-architecture-in-organizations/