Tom Emmer SEC Gensler | Unbiased Regulator or Bank-Loyal?

During a hearing held on September 27th, Representative Tom Emmer hinted at a potential bias in Securities and Exchange Commission Chair Gary Gensler’s regulatory approach, owing to his extensive background in Wall Street. In a session convened by the House Financial Services Committee, United States Representative Tom Emmer voiced his reservations regarding Gary Gensler, the Chair of the Securities and Exchange Commission, on September 27th. Emmer asserted that Gensler’s allegiance to Wall Street appeared to come at the expense of fostering innovation, healthy competition, and the welfare of everyday Americans. Over the course of a four-minute inquiry, Emmer subtly alluded to Gensler’s financial background, which notably encompassed an 18-year tenure at Goldman Sachs, where he held the position of a partner and co-head of finance. Emmer’s viewpoint posited that Gensler’s deep ties to the financial sector might hinder his capacity to serve as an impartial regulator. Emmer articulated his concern with the following query: “Considering your illustrious 18-year career at one of the world’s largest banks and the substantial financial wealth you accumulated therein, can you genuinely act as an unbiased regulator without showing favoritism toward major financial intermediaries?” According to a transcript of the hearing, Emmer further elaborated: “To clarify, sir, does this perspective have no connection to the apprehension you voiced in a speech last year, where you remarked, ‘Over the past year, several bank executives have shared their concerns with me about the sheer number of depositors who have moved money from their bank accounts into crypto-related exchanges and wallets’?” Gensler was obliged to respond with simple “yes” or “no” answers to the questions posed, without the liberty to expound further. In response to the initial query regarding his ability to regulate impartially, Gensler promptly affirmed, saying, “Absolutely, sir.” However, when confronted with the second question, Gensler attempted to provide context to his earlier statement but was not permitted to do so. Representative Emmer has strategically positioned himself as an advocate for the cryptocurrency industry, advocating for regulatory clarity within the United States, particularly in the wake of the SEC’s intensified scrutiny of cryptocurrency firms commencing in 2022, subsequent to the collapse of the cryptocurrency exchange FTX. An examination of Emmer’s primary financial supporters between 2021 and 2022 reveals significant contributions from venture capital firm Andreessen Horowitz, a prominent investor in the cryptocurrency sphere. As per data available on Open Secrets, donations to Emmer from the securities and investment sectors amounted to $418,020. During the hearing, Representative Patrick McHenry also floated the possibility of subpoenaing the SEC for documents related to the former CEO of FTX, Sam Bankman-Fried. According to McHenry, Gensler’s actions appeared to stifle the digital asset ecosystem and raised concerns about transparency between the commission, FTX, and Bankman-Fried.